New York Times Asks Court to Sanction OpenAI in US Copyright Dispute

A coalition of newspapers led by The New York Times has asked a federal court to sanction OpenAI, alleging the company lied about its ability to search for copyrighted content in ChatGPT and deleted billions of relevant conversations. The motion marks a dramatic escalation in the high-stakes copyright battle over AI training data.

Last Updated: September 12, 2026 Editorial Process
Editorial Process
See more of Inside AI's trusted news by adding us as a preferred source on Google.
AI neural network visualization
Published on: July 9, 2026

July 9, 2026, (Inside AI) — A coalition of newspapers led by The New York Times asked a federal court in Manhattan on Thursday to sanction OpenAI, alleging the AI company lied about its ability to search its systems for copyrighted content used in training ChatGPT.

The motion, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, claims OpenAI falsely stated it could not search its large language models for the newspapers’ articles while secretly having done so before the first lawsuit was even filed. The newspapers also accuse OpenAI of deleting or rendering unsearchable billions of relevant ChatGPT conversations.

The plaintiffs are seeking sanctions including attorneys’ fees and a court finding that OpenAI’s chat logs prove misuse of copyrighted works. OpenAI spokespeople did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The original lawsuit, initiated by The New York Times in 2023, accuses OpenAI and its largest backer Microsoft of using millions of articles without permission to train the models behind ChatGPT. The case is a bellwether in a wave of copyright disputes against AI developers, including Anthropic and Meta, brought by authors, artists, and music labels.

Read: How AI Firms Can Pay Creators Fairly for Training Data

The Deletion Allegation and Its Broader Implications

The filing reveals a deeper rift: OpenAI allegedly deleted billions of ChatGPT conversation logs, which the newspapers argue could have contained evidence of infringing outputs. This accusation moves beyond simple discovery disputes into potential spoliation of evidence, a serious charge that could reshape how AI companies manage training data records.

Legal experts note that if proven, such deletion could trigger adverse inference rulings—where a court assumes the destroyed evidence was unfavorable. This would be unprecedented in AI copyright litigation and could force companies to implement rigorous data retention policies, fundamentally altering AI development practices.

The newspapers’ lead attorney, Ian Crosby, stated:

“For over two years, OpenAI lied to The Times, The Daily News Plaintiffs, the public, and the court. It claimed searching ChatGPT outputs for copies of The Times’ and the Daily News Plaintiffs’ content was infeasible, burdensome, and invasive of users’ privacy – while at the same time concealing that it had already done such searches.”

This statement underscores the core allegation: OpenAI’s public and legal posture contradicted its internal capabilities, potentially misleading the court about the feasibility of detecting copyright infringement in AI outputs.

At the heart of the dispute is a technical question: Can AI models be reliably searched for specific copyrighted content? OpenAI had argued that searching training data or output logs was impractical due to the scale and structure of models like GPT-4. However, the newspapers claim an OpenAI employee testified that the company had already performed multiple searches for their content, suggesting such searches are not only possible but were conducted covertly.

Read: OpenAI Defeats xAI Trade Secret Lawsuit as Judge Dismisses Case Permanently

This revelation challenges the industry’s common defense that AI systems are “black boxes” incapable of tracing individual data points. Researchers have demonstrated methods for membership inference attacks that can determine if specific data was used in training, but these techniques are often probabilistic. The newspapers’ filing implies OpenAI may have more deterministic search capabilities than previously disclosed.

The privacy argument adds another layer. OpenAI claimed that searching user conversations would violate privacy, yet the newspapers argue this was a pretext. If OpenAI did search chats without user consent, it could face separate privacy scrutiny, creating a Catch-22 for the company: either it lied about the searches or it violated user privacy.

The case is part of a broader reckoning over fair use in AI training. While tech companies argue that training on publicly available data is transformative, publishers contend it undermines their business models. The outcome here could set a precedent for dozens of pending cases, potentially requiring AI developers to license training data or face stricter discovery obligations.

As the litigation unfolds, the focus will likely shift to the forensic examination of OpenAI’s data practices. The court’s response to the sanctions motion may signal how seriously it views the alleged deception, with possible repercussions for AI transparency standards industry-wide.

More from Inside AI

  • Features, Interviews, Press Releases

    Beyond Transcripts: Modulate Secures $25M to Scale Frontier Audio-Native AI Architecture Against Monolithic LLMs

    September 28, 2026
  • AI Policy & Regulation

    Who Is Alice Huang, the Woman at the Center of NVIDIA’s Crisis?

    November 22, 2026
  • AI Safety

    Signal Blocks Mobile Screenshots Over AI Surveillance Threat

    November 22, 2026
  • Artificial Intelligence (AI)

    Hideo Kojima Warns AI May Sap Joy of Creation Despite Business Benefits

    November 22, 2026
  • AI In Business

    Anthropic Ends First Week at $1.6T After Largest IPO in History

    November 22, 2026
  • Cybersecurity AI

    Ex-CIA Officer: AI Industry Wide Open to Honey Trap Spies

    November 22, 2026
  • AI In Business

    NBP Opens AI and Robotics Lab at Abbottabad Public School

    November 21, 2026
  • AI Policy & Regulation

    Trump Warns US Tech Firms of Penalties for Overseas Data Centres

    November 21, 2026
  • Cybersecurity AI

    Kerala Businessman Loses Rs 1.45 Crore to Deepfake Investment Scam

    November 21, 2026

Never Miss a Breakthrough

Join 50,000+ readers who get our daily AI intelligence briefing. No fluff, just what matters.

Join Our Newsletter Community

Subscribe

Inside AI is an independent publication covering artificial intelligence news, machine learning research, and the tools shaping the future of technology. No hype. Just what's happening in the AI world.

Topics

  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Machine Learning
  • Generative AI
  • Agentic AI
  • Vibe Coding
  • Prompt Engineering
  • AI Policy & Regulation
  • AI Hardware & Infrastructure
  • AI Tools
  • AI In Business
  • Robotics
  • Cybersecurity AI
  • AI Safety
  • AI Tools & Reviews (Coming soon)

Company

  • Editorial Standards
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact
  • About Us

Others

  • Press Releases
  • Features
  • Sponsored Content
  • Advertise with us
  • Newsletter

© 2026 Inside AI. All rights reserved.

Designed by Blue Flare Digital